We build a phone alert system, so we have a side in this comparison. We have tried to write it fairly.
Pagers
Strengths:
- They work without internet and without the customer's phone.
- They vibrate hard in the customer's hand, so a nearby customer rarely misses them.
- The customer doesn't have to do anything.
Limits:
- You buy the devices, and over time they break, go missing and need charging.
- There are only so many; at peak times you can run out.
- They pass from hand to hand and need cleaning.
- Their range is limited, so they don't help if the customer wanders far.
Phone alerts (such as Wimo)
Strengths:
- No devices to buy, charge or collect; a QR poster is enough.
- No limit on how many orders run at once.
- Customers see their order's status on their own screen (“Preparing”, then “Ready”).
Limits:
- They need internet on the customer's phone.
- The page has to stay open with sound on; if the phone locks or the browser is in the background, the alert may not arrive.
- Some customers don't want to use their phone, or their battery is low.
- The customer has to take a step: scan and type the number.
So which one?
- If your customers' internet is very weak, or most of them don't use their phones, calling out numbers or pagers are more reliable.
- If most customers sit with their phones and have internet, phone alerts save you the cost and handling of devices.
- Many cafés combine two methods: a phone alert for those who want it, and calling the number out loud for everyone. That is what we recommend with Wimo too.